TCO/ROI Analysis: VMware/Broadcom VCF Costs vs. AWS
How would three years on AWS compare with your current VMware/Broadcom VCF costs? This brochure presents a TCO and ROI analysis across four AWS migration paths, from Amazon Elastic VMware Service to AWS native services. Illustrative public sector scenarios show 62% to 76% three-year savings, ROI of up to 302%, and payback in as little as two to four months. Download the brochure, then contact us about a custom TCO analysis for your environment.
How does migrating from VMware Broadcom VCF to AWS impact our total cost of ownership?
Public sector organizations that move from VMware Broadcom VCF to AWS typically see meaningful TCO and ROI improvements over a three-year period, based on AWS-commissioned research and Optimization and Licensing Assessment (OLA) data.
Across four validated migration paths, organizations have seen:
- Up to 66% infrastructure cost savings compared to on-premises VMware environments.
- 62–76% three-year cost reduction versus staying on VMware Broadcom VCF on-premises.
- 30–70% compute cost reduction using AWS right-sizing, Savings Plans, and Spot Instances.
- 45–77% reduction in Windows Server and SQL Server licensing costs through a mix of BYOL optimization and License Included options.
For a typical mid-size public sector environment (around 500 VMs, 100 Windows Server cores, and 50 SQL Server Enterprise cores):
- The EC2 Rehost path (lift-and-shift using AWS Application Migration Service) often delivers the fastest payback, with the migration cost typically recovered in 2–4 months.
- AWS Native replatforming (e.g., to managed services like Amazon Aurora and Amazon RDS) tends to provide the highest long-term savings, with up to ~75% savings over three years in some modeled scenarios.
In addition to direct savings, moving to AWS eliminates several VMware Broadcom cost risks:
- The 20% late-renewal penalty on first-year subscription price.
- The 72-core minimum purchase requirement, which especially impacts smaller environments.
- Forced bundle purchases and 3-year upfront payment requirements for non-VCF licenses.
When AWS funding programs (such as MAP, VMP, and AMA) are applied, the net migration cost for a mid-size environment is often less than 15% of the first year’s savings, meaning the project can effectively pay for itself within the first few months.
Where do the biggest Windows and SQL Server licensing savings come from on AWS?
The OLA assessment focuses heavily on optimizing Windows Server and SQL Server licensing as you move from VMware Broadcom VCF to AWS. The largest savings typically come from a combination of right-sizing, bring-your-own-license (BYOL), and replatforming.
Windows Server licensing savings
Two main levers drive Windows Server savings:
- Right-sizing over-provisioned VMs
Many VMware VMs are oversized. The OLA analyzes actual utilization and maps workloads to appropriately sized AWS instances. This typically reduces the number of licensed cores by about 30–50%.
- BYOL vs. License Included
- If you have eligible perpetual Windows Server licenses (purchased before October 1, 2019 or under active Enterprise Enrollment), you can bring your own licenses on AWS Dedicated Hosts.
- For newer versions, AWS License Included options provide the OS license bundled with the instance, often at a lower effective cost than buying and maintaining separate licenses.
The OLA models both options per workload and recommends the most cost-effective mix.
SQL Server licensing savings
SQL Server is often one of the largest cost drivers in VMware environments. The OLA identifies savings through:
- License Mobility with Software Assurance
If you have active Software Assurance, you can use License Mobility to bring SQL Server licenses to AWS without tenancy restrictions. This lets you preserve existing investments while moving to AWS infrastructure.
- Replatforming to managed database services
For suitable workloads, the OLA may recommend moving from SQL Server to:
- Amazon Aurora PostgreSQL, or
- Amazon RDS (including SQL Server Express/Standard where appropriate).
In these cases, you can eliminate SQL Server licensing entirely for those workloads and shift to a managed service consumption model.
In modeled public sector scenarios, these strategies combine to deliver:
- 45–77% reduction in Windows Server and SQL Server licensing costs overall.
- For some AWS Native paths, 40–60% SQL license reductions and, for replatformed workloads, complete removal of SQL Server license costs.
The OLA provides a detailed, workload-by-workload view of which licenses to bring, which to replace with License Included, and where replatforming makes financial sense.
How do AWS funding programs reduce our migration cost and risk?
AWS offers several funding programs that are designed to lower the financial barrier to moving off VMware Broadcom VCF and to de-risk the migration process. For many public sector organizations, these programs significantly reduce or even fully cover assessment and migration execution costs.
Key AWS funding programs
- Optimization and Licensing Assessment (OLA)
- Provides a full assessment at no cost to qualifying organizations.
- Analyzes your actual environment (VMs, utilization, licenses) to build a custom TCO and ROI model.
- Identifies right-sizing opportunities and optimal BYOL vs. License Included strategies.
- Migration Acceleration Program (MAP)
- Offers funding tied to your annual recurring revenue (ARR) on AWS.
- Includes up to 5% of ARR (max $75K) for assessment and up to 20% of ARR (max $2M) for mobilization.
- Helps pay for partner-led migration work and AWS services during the transition.
- VMware Modernization Program (VMP) and AWS Modernization Assurance (AMA)
- Provide additional service credits and funding for modernization efforts.
- Can cover up to 25–30% of post-modernization ARR, with caps up to $1M in some cases.
- Often include AWS-funded ISV migration tools and partner services.
Impact on net migration cost
When these programs are combined:
- The OLA assessment is typically fully funded (no cost to you).
- Migration execution (labor and tooling) is often reduced to around $50K–$120K after MAP, VMP, and AMA support, depending on scope.
- For a mid-size environment (~500 VMs), the net migration cost after funding is often less than 15% of the first year’s savings.
- Because annual savings can reach $957K–$1.16M in modeled scenarios, the migration typically pays for itself within 2–4 months of being in production.
In parallel, moving to AWS removes ongoing VMware Broadcom cost risks such as the 20% late-renewal penalty, the 72-core minimum purchase requirement (a 125% overhead for some small K–12 districts), and forced bundle purchases. This combination of funding support and risk reduction helps agencies reimagine their infrastructure strategy with more predictable costs and faster time to value.